Quilt

Artist/Maker
Atwater, Eleanor McCauley
Place Made
Orange County North Carolina United States of America
Date Made
circa 1870
Medium
cotton
Dimensions
HOA: 83; WOA: 80 3/4
Accession Number
3414.1
Description
MAKER: Eleanor “Ellen” McCauley was born in 1801 to Matthew McCauley (1750-1832) and Martha Ann Johnston (1760-1848) in Orange County, North Carolina. Matthew McCauley was an emigrant from County Antrim, Ireland, to North Carolina. He was a Lieutenant, 10th North Carolina Regiment, in the Continental Army. McCauley (with his brother William) was a donor of 150 Acres of land for the founding of The University of North Carolina in Chapel Hill. Eleanor McCauley married Reverend Wilson Atwater (1797-1885) in 1819. The 1860 census of Eleanor and Wilson reflects the ownership of 22 slaves.

DESCRIPTION: Applique quilt featuring the princess feather design on a chrome orange cotton ground. There are nine applique blocks with green sashing in between. The North Carolina Museum of History lists “Wild Cucumber” as an alternate name for the “Princess Feather” in a catalogue of its exhibit held in 1974.

RELATED OBJECTS: Another quilt made by Ellen McCauley Atwater is in the MESDA Collection (acc. 3414.2).

History
This quilt, along with one other in the MESDA collection, lived a portion of their lives on the staircase landing of Emily Anzonetta Atwater Pritchard’s Chapel Hill home. According to family history, every night, young William Grady Pritchard (1896-1979) would choose one to carry up the stairs to his bedroom on the third floor, squirreling them away until his mother Emily brought them back down. According to one of her daughters, Emily’s hoard was enormous: seventy-five quilts in all. Emily chose to inscribe one of these quilts to her daughter, Mary Eleanor Pritchard (1883-1970), with the added note that it was “her mother’s.” Mary, in turn, added an ink pen inscription in 1943 when she gave this quilt to her niece, Julia Atwater Bristow (1925-2010).

Family matriarch Eleanor McCauley Atwater may have been the maker of these two nine-block quilts. One is in a variation of the “Princess Feather” or “Wild Cucumber” pattern, the other a variation on “Carpenter’s Star.” The combination of fabric colors, including bright chrome orange, helps date them to circa 1870, towards the end of Eleanor’s life. All of the fabrics are solid, in keeping with many quilts made during the Civil War and reconstruction in North Carolina. One was quilted onto what may be a locally produced brown “Alamance plaid” backing fabric with irregular stitches, likely the work of several individuals.

Perhaps some of the other hands involved were her daughters. The Atwater girls, as they married, stayed nearby. Daughter Celia Atwater remained single and continued living in the household of her parents until their deaths, then resided with her niece Emily and little William in their Chapel Hill house.

Credit Line
Gift of Miss Julia Bristow