Both sets of andirons were originally attributed to Charleston, South Carolina (see “A School of Charleston, South Carolina Brass Andirons,” by Bradford L. Rauschenberg in the May 1979 issue of the MESDA Journal). In his November 1992 MESDA Journal article, “Reconsidering Charleston Brass Andirons, Types II and III: An Essay on the use of Theory Replacement in Material Culture,” Rauschenberg replaces his original hypothesis with the theory that this style of andiron was actually made in England, possibly for the Charleston market. Rauschenberg writes:
“The James Douglas Account Book in the William L. Clements Library at the University of Michigan is at the heart of my reattribution of these objects.” (page 46)
The account book includes an entry describing cargo bound for Charleston from a number of London merchants including Taylor and Bailey. The Taylor and Bailey shipment included:
“2 [pair] of neat Square Eng[rav]d brass pillar Do [Fire dogs], with arch’d feet & brass vase h[ea]ds @ 18/ 1:16[,] 2 pr Do Do [@] 25 /2:10[,] 1 pr of large Strong Do1:11[,] 2 pr of Do wth. very very neat Claw feet [@] 35/[L]3:10…1 pair of very neat large new make d[ou]ble Fire dogs with neat Engd. Princes metal oblisk pillars Claw feet vase heads wth. a very neat openwork Eliptic & Scroul [sic] border Engd. [L] 3:13:6[,] 1 Pair of very Strong Single Do fluted pillars & Strong Claw feet with bright horses [L] 2:8 [,] 2 pair of Single brass Mounted fire dogs, with Square oblisk Pillars Engd. arch feet & vase heads [L0]:17…1 Neat New Pattern openwork brass Serpentine fender with a Moulding & bottom plate….” (Rauschenberg 47).